/| Mario Kart PC |\

What's the most underrated and what's the most overrated Mario Kart Track ?

smile

Page :  1 

Messages 19 - Koopa Koopa
vs5999 pts ★ Novice
battle5000 pts ★ Novice
France
Hello guys,
I was curious to know what's the most underrated track and what's the most overrated one in every Mario Kart. In my opinion, :

- Super Mario Kart :
Underrated : Mario Circuit 4
Overrated : Vanilla Lake 2
- Mario Kart 64 :
Underrated : Choco Mountain
Overrated : Royal Raceway
- Mario Kart: Super Circuit :
Underrated : Bowser Castle 3/Lakeside Park
Overrated : Cheese Land/Ribbon Road
- Mario Kart: Double Dash
Underrated : Mushroom Bridge/Bowser Castle
Overrated : Baby Park
- Mario Kart DS :
Underrated : Shroom Ridge/GCN Mushroom Bridge/N64 Choco Mountain/GCN Yoshi Circuit
Overrated : Figure-8 Circuit/SNES Mario Circuit 1
- Mario Kart Wii :
Underrated : Moonview Highway/Bowser Castle/GBA Bowser Castle 3/N64 Boser Castle
Overrated : DK Summit
- Mario Kart 7 :
Underrated : GCN Daisy Cruiser/DS Airship Fortress
Overrated : None
- Mario Kart 8 Deluxe :
Underrated : Dolphin Shoals/DS Shroom Ridge/Tour Ninja Hideaway/Mute City
Overrated : SNES Donut Plains 3/GCN Sherbet Land
Messages 167 - Bowser Bowser
vs5000 pts ★ Novice
battle5000 pts ★ Novice
Canada
Most underrated in the whole series is easily Sky High Sundae, never understood why people disliked it past 'it's a rectangle' which shouldn't instantly turn you off from a track, especially such an interesting one

Most overrated in the series is probably Tick Tock Clock, like it's interesting and a cool reference but the actual track isn't too fun imo
up3
ok1
thumbsup2
Messages 1751 - Golden Mario Golden Mario
vs20229 pts ★ Legend
battle6349 pts ★ Racer
United Kingdom
UraniumMan wrote:
Most underrated in the whole series is easily Sky High Sundae, never understood why people disliked it past 'it's a rectangle' which shouldn't instantly turn you off from a track, especially such an interesting one

Most overrated in the series is probably Tick Tock Clock, like it's interesting and a cool reference but the actual track isn't too fun imo

not to mention thatt TTC's layout is basically an over complicated figure eight too
thumbsup3
Messages 19 - Koopa Koopa
vs5999 pts ★ Novice
battle5000 pts ★ Novice
France
Twilight wrote:
UraniumMan wrote:
Most underrated in the whole series is easily Sky High Sundae, never understood why people disliked it past 'it's a rectangle' which shouldn't instantly turn you off from a track, especially such an interesting one

Most overrated in the series is probably Tick Tock Clock, like it's interesting and a cool reference but the actual track isn't too fun imo

not to mention thatt TTC's layout is basically an over complicated figure eight too


Yeah, but I still love this track. I stopped playign MKDS when I sold my 2DS and my 3DS XL for a Xbox One S in 2018, and I stilled remember this track of the game
Messages 2899 - King Mario King Mario
vs58255 pts ★ Titan
battle11492 pts ★ Champion
Barbados
Most underrated most of the Tour cities tbh

Most overrated Coconut Mall, Waluigi Pinball & Wii Rainbow Road
thinking1
check1
up1
rob_dabbing1
Messages 492 - Metal Luigi Metal Luigi
vs4978 pts ★ Budding pilot
battle5000 pts ★ Novice
United States
Ok here we go.
Quick note: for retro’s i’m not using tracks i already used.
Snes
Overrated: rainbow road
Underrated: koopa beach 1
64
Overrated: wario stadium
Underrated: banshee boardwalk
Gba
Overrated: cheese land (not the 8 version
Underrated: bc2
Gcn
Overrated: baby park
Underrated: luigi circuit
Ds (nitro)
Overrated: desert hills (this choice was really hard)
Underrated: mario circuit
Ds (retro)
Overrated: moo moo farm
Underrated: peach circuit
Wii (nitro)
Overrated: coconut mall
Underrated: daisy circuit (wow 4 circuit tracks in a row)
Wii (retro)
Overrated: gba bc3
Underrated: shy guy beach
7 (nitro)
Overrated: rainbow road (fight me)
Underrated: shy guy bazzar
7 (retro)
Overrated: waluigi pinball
Underrated: snes mc2
8 non bcp (nitro)
Overrated: mount wario (fight me yet again)
Underrated: thwomp ruins
8 non bcp (retro)
Overrated: moo moo meadows
Underrated: sherbet land
8 old dlc
Overrated: animal crossing
Underrated: super bell subway
8 bcp (for this one i did top 3)
Overrated: 1. Shroom ridge 2. Rock rock mountain. 3. Koopa cape
Underrated: 1. Waluigi stadium, 2. Sydney sprint. 3. Snow land.
I’m not saying that any of these tracks are terrible or insanely good i just have a different opinion than most people. Also some of these i only find a smidge overrated because there were some good tracks.
mario_facepalm1
super_hammer1
Messages 167 - Bowser Bowser
vs5000 pts ★ Novice
battle5000 pts ★ Novice
Canada
Most underrated most of the Tour cities tbh

Most overrated Coconut Mall, Waluigi Pinball & Wii Rainbow Road

Absolutely agree on the Tour city tracks, most are insanely good with Tokyo being the only major exception.

However, while I personally disagree but understand why you may dislike Coconut Mall and Waluigi Pinball, I don't understand what's to dislike about Wii Rainbow Road. It's just chaotic fun, items are important, the boosts make it really feel like you're going fast, it's just a great track all around.
Messages 2899 - King Mario King Mario
vs58255 pts ★ Titan
battle11492 pts ★ Champion
Barbados
UraniumMan wrote:
Most underrated most of the Tour cities tbh

Most overrated Coconut Mall, Waluigi Pinball & Wii Rainbow Road

Absolutely agree on the Tour city tracks, most are insanely good with Tokyo being the only major exception.

However, while I personally disagree but understand why you may dislike Coconut Mall and Waluigi Pinball, I don't understand what's to dislike about Wii Rainbow Road. It's just chaotic fun, items are important, the boosts make it really feel like you're going fast, it's just a great track all around.

It really isn't all that imo. Rainbow Roads in general are just very boring, with nothing going on. It's just space, they really aren't anything special. Except GCN, which was made to feel like an actual finale.
mario_shrug2
mario_facepalm1
mario_no1
Messages 19 - Koopa Koopa
vs5999 pts ★ Novice
battle5000 pts ★ Novice
France
Ssg-132 wrote:
Ok here we go.
Quick note: for retro’s i’m not using tracks i already used.
Snes
Overrated: rainbow road
Underrated: koopa beach 1
64
Overrated: wario stadium
Underrated: banshee boardwalk
Gba
Overrated: cheese land (not the 8 version
Underrated: bc2
Gcn
Overrated: baby park
Underrated: luigi circuit
Ds (nitro)
Overrated: desert hills (this choice was really hard)
Underrated: mario circuit
Ds (retro)
Overrated: moo moo farm
Underrated: peach circuit
Wii (nitro)
Overrated: coconut mall
Underrated: daisy circuit (wow 4 circuit tracks in a row)
Wii (retro)
Overrated: gba bc3
Underrated: shy guy beach
7 (nitro)
Overrated: rainbow road (fight me)
Underrated: shy guy bazzar
7 (retro)
Overrated: waluigi pinball
Underrated: snes mc2
8 non bcp (nitro)
Overrated: mount wario (fight me yet again)
Underrated: thwomp ruins
8 non bcp (retro)
Overrated: moo moo meadows
Underrated: sherbet land
8 old dlc
Overrated: animal crossing
Underrated: super bell subway
8 bcp (for this one i did top 3)
Overrated: 1. Shroom ridge 2. Rock rock mountain. 3. Koopa cape
Underrated: 1. Waluigi stadium, 2. Sydney sprint. 3. Snow land.
I’m not saying that any of these tracks are terrible or insanely good i just have a different opinion than most people. Also some of these i only find a smidge overrated because there were some good tracks.


Oh hell nah, how 3ds rainbow road is overrated ? Such as Koopa Cape and shroom ridge ? But thank you for saying Waluigi Pinball and Coconut Mall are overrated
Messages 167 - Bowser Bowser
vs5000 pts ★ Novice
battle5000 pts ★ Novice
Canada
Ssg-132 wrote:
Ok here we go.
Quick note: for retro’s i’m not using tracks i already used.
Snes
Overrated: rainbow road
Underrated: koopa beach 1
64
Overrated: wario stadium
Underrated: banshee boardwalk
Gba
Overrated: cheese land (not the 8 version
Underrated: bc2
Gcn
Overrated: baby park
Underrated: luigi circuit
Ds (nitro)
Overrated: desert hills (this choice was really hard)
Underrated: mario circuit
Ds (retro)
Overrated: moo moo farm
Underrated: peach circuit
Wii (nitro)
Overrated: coconut mall
Underrated: daisy circuit (wow 4 circuit tracks in a row)
Wii (retro)
Overrated: gba bc3
Underrated: shy guy beach
7 (nitro)
Overrated: rainbow road (fight me)
Underrated: shy guy bazzar
7 (retro)
Overrated: waluigi pinball
Underrated: snes mc2
8 non bcp (nitro)
Overrated: mount wario (fight me yet again)
Underrated: thwomp ruins
8 non bcp (retro)
Overrated: moo moo meadows
Underrated: sherbet land
8 old dlc
Overrated: animal crossing
Underrated: super bell subway
8 bcp (for this one i did top 3)
Overrated: 1. Shroom ridge 2. Rock rock mountain. 3. Koopa cape
Underrated: 1. Waluigi stadium, 2. Sydney sprint. 3. Snow land.
I’m not saying that any of these tracks are terrible or insanely good i just have a different opinion than most people. Also some of these i only find a smidge overrated because there were some good tracks.


Oh hell nah, how 3ds rainbow road is overrated ? Such as Koopa Cape and shroom ridge ? But thank you for saying Waluigi Pinball and Coconut Mall are overrated

Shroom Ridge sucks tbh. I take back what I said before about Tick Tock Clock, Shroom Ridge is easily by far the most overrated
Messages 466 - Metal Luigi Metal Luigi
vs14484 pts ★ Champion
battle7855 pts ★ Racer
United States
UraniumMan wrote:
Ssg-132 wrote:
Ok here we go.
Quick note: for retro’s i’m not using tracks i already used.
Snes
Overrated: rainbow road
Underrated: koopa beach 1
64
Overrated: wario stadium
Underrated: banshee boardwalk
Gba
Overrated: cheese land (not the 8 version
Underrated: bc2
Gcn
Overrated: baby park
Underrated: luigi circuit
Ds (nitro)
Overrated: desert hills (this choice was really hard)
Underrated: mario circuit
Ds (retro)
Overrated: moo moo farm
Underrated: peach circuit
Wii (nitro)
Overrated: coconut mall
Underrated: daisy circuit (wow 4 circuit tracks in a row)
Wii (retro)
Overrated: gba bc3
Underrated: shy guy beach
7 (nitro)
Overrated: rainbow road (fight me)
Underrated: shy guy bazzar
7 (retro)
Overrated: waluigi pinball
Underrated: snes mc2
8 non bcp (nitro)
Overrated: mount wario (fight me yet again)
Underrated: thwomp ruins
8 non bcp (retro)
Overrated: moo moo meadows
Underrated: sherbet land
8 old dlc
Overrated: animal crossing
Underrated: super bell subway
8 bcp (for this one i did top 3)
Overrated: 1. Shroom ridge 2. Rock rock mountain. 3. Koopa cape
Underrated: 1. Waluigi stadium, 2. Sydney sprint. 3. Snow land.
I’m not saying that any of these tracks are terrible or insanely good i just have a different opinion than most people. Also some of these i only find a smidge overrated because there were some good tracks.


Oh hell nah, how 3ds rainbow road is overrated ? Such as Koopa Cape and shroom ridge ? But thank you for saying Waluigi Pinball and Coconut Mall are overrated

Shroom Ridge sucks tbh. I take back what I said before about Tick Tock Clock, Shroom Ridge is easily by far the most overrated



Shroom Ridge? I mean its your opinion but, Koopa Beach 2 gotta gohttps://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcS2BiH9otubNVXWJieWKoUJdz5xhUJ14m0rl5pcLY3QRHehJbXeyeyAPIiViTUDX9p1hrc&usqp=CAU
Messages 19 - Koopa Koopa
vs5999 pts ★ Novice
battle5000 pts ★ Novice
France
UraniumMan wrote:
Ssg-132 wrote:
Ok here we go.
Quick note: for retro’s i’m not using tracks i already used.
Snes
Overrated: rainbow road
Underrated: koopa beach 1
64
Overrated: wario stadium
Underrated: banshee boardwalk
Gba
Overrated: cheese land (not the 8 version
Underrated: bc2
Gcn
Overrated: baby park
Underrated: luigi circuit
Ds (nitro)
Overrated: desert hills (this choice was really hard)
Underrated: mario circuit
Ds (retro)
Overrated: moo moo farm
Underrated: peach circuit
Wii (nitro)
Overrated: coconut mall
Underrated: daisy circuit (wow 4 circuit tracks in a row)
Wii (retro)
Overrated: gba bc3
Underrated: shy guy beach
7 (nitro)
Overrated: rainbow road (fight me)
Underrated: shy guy bazzar
7 (retro)
Overrated: waluigi pinball
Underrated: snes mc2
8 non bcp (nitro)
Overrated: mount wario (fight me yet again)
Underrated: thwomp ruins
8 non bcp (retro)
Overrated: moo moo meadows
Underrated: sherbet land
8 old dlc
Overrated: animal crossing
Underrated: super bell subway
8 bcp (for this one i did top 3)
Overrated: 1. Shroom ridge 2. Rock rock mountain. 3. Koopa cape
Underrated: 1. Waluigi stadium, 2. Sydney sprint. 3. Snow land.
I’m not saying that any of these tracks are terrible or insanely good i just have a different opinion than most people. Also some of these i only find a smidge overrated because there were some good tracks.


Oh hell nah, how 3ds rainbow road is overrated ? Such as Koopa Cape and shroom ridge ? But thank you for saying Waluigi Pinball and Coconut Mall are overrated

Shroom Ridge sucks tbh. I take back what I said before about Tick Tock Clock, Shroom Ridge is easily by far the most overrated



Shroom Ridge? I mean its your opinion but, Koopa Beach 2 gotta gohttps://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcS2BiH9otubNVXWJieWKoUJdz5xhUJ14m0rl5pcLY3QRHehJbXeyeyAPIiViTUDX9p1hrc&usqp=CAU


Nah I think SNES Koopa Beach 2 deserves the same fate than SNES Choco Island 2 and N64 Frappe Snowland : to be destroyed
Messages 19 - Koopa Koopa
vs5999 pts ★ Novice
battle5000 pts ★ Novice
France
UraniumMan wrote:
Most underrated most of the Tour cities tbh

Most overrated Coconut Mall, Waluigi Pinball & Wii Rainbow Road

Absolutely agree on the Tour city tracks, most are insanely good with Tokyo being the only major exception.

However, while I personally disagree but understand why you may dislike Coconut Mall and Waluigi Pinball, I don't understand what's to dislike about Wii Rainbow Road. It's just chaotic fun, items are important, the boosts make it really feel like you're going fast, it's just a great track all around.


Yeah same for me. Coconut Mall and Waluigi Pinball have  like 15-20% of the track which is really original, whereas the other parts are boring.
And Wii Rainbow Road is indeed really really fun and chaotic, especially if you play on the Wii with the legendary Wii Wheel (I still playing with it)
Messages 19 - Koopa Koopa
vs5999 pts ★ Novice
battle5000 pts ★ Novice
France
Ssg-132 wrote:
Ok here we go.
Quick note: for retro’s i’m not using tracks i already used.
Snes
Overrated: rainbow road
Underrated: koopa beach 1
64
Overrated: wario stadium
Underrated: banshee boardwalk
Gba
Overrated: cheese land (not the 8 version
Underrated: bc2
Gcn
Overrated: baby park
Underrated: luigi circuit
Ds (nitro)
Overrated: desert hills (this choice was really hard)
Underrated: mario circuit
Ds (retro)
Overrated: moo moo farm
Underrated: peach circuit
Wii (nitro)
Overrated: coconut mall
Underrated: daisy circuit (wow 4 circuit tracks in a row)
Wii (retro)
Overrated: gba bc3
Underrated: shy guy beach
7 (nitro)
Overrated: rainbow road (fight me)
Underrated: shy guy bazzar
7 (retro)
Overrated: waluigi pinball
Underrated: snes mc2
8 non bcp (nitro)
Overrated: mount wario (fight me yet again)
Underrated: thwomp ruins
8 non bcp (retro)
Overrated: moo moo meadows
Underrated: sherbet land
8 old dlc
Overrated: animal crossing
Underrated: super bell subway
8 bcp (for this one i did top 3)
Overrated: 1. Shroom ridge 2. Rock rock mountain. 3. Koopa cape
Underrated: 1. Waluigi stadium, 2. Sydney sprint. 3. Snow land.
I’m not saying that any of these tracks are terrible or insanely good i just have a different opinion than most people. Also some of these i only find a smidge overrated because there were some good tracks.


Everything was fine from the start to the nitro Wii. And then, retro Wii tracks arrived, and I did a cardiac crisis from this moment to the end. Shy Guy Beach is horrible if you don't use the Magikruiser. But I still agree on two points : Shy Guy Bazaar and Thwomp Ruins are really underrated. Never understood why

Page :  1 

Back to International forum
Back to the forum