Underrated & Overrated Tracks

Here you can talk about what tracks YOU think are praised too much or too little.
Personally, I think DK Jungle is underrated as it is a unique track and has a cool temple section. Before I get bombarded with comments about this CONTROVERSIAL opinion, I believe that Waluigi's Pinball is overrated. Don't get me wrong! It's a solid 8.5 - 9/10, but there is a LOT of tracks better than this, and if I list them, it will take a while.

Vancouver is the definition of underrated.

Now Music Park is clearly the most overrated track I've ever seen. Don't get me wrong, it's not bad. It's a solid B Tier. But y'all are acting like it's the best track of all time when it's really not. The theme is unique, but it's much too short.

I'm gonna say this right here and now. BCP GBA Sky Garden is underrated, and if not, the most underrated track. imo it's layout change was a great upgrade and, to be honest, is even better than the original and DS version. Now, what do I think is the most overrated track? Wii Rainbow Road. And no I do not hate it merely because of the fact there wasn't DS Rainbow Road in the BCP, I just don't like Wii RR. For starters, the layout sucks and the only unique feature in the track is where you jump from one side to another using the half pipes. But that's it. Everything else in the track is just unoriginal and boring or used before. So, my final thoughts? I highly despise Wii RR. I can't be the only one thinking that right?

Honestly, DS rainbow road is one of the WORST Rainbow Roads there is. It has a simplistic layout, the only thing that sticks out are the loop-de-loops which are the JANKIEST things in the game, and with how you have to drift in the DS version
It's overrated and definitely C tier.
Personally, Wii Rainbow Road is one of the best rainbow roads. Probably second best (best is 3DS obvs) But it is unique and was definitely a highlight of the game.

In my opinion, DS Rainbow Road's music sounds like it pushed the DS's music chip to it's boundaries.



And I don't think that DS Rainbow Road is overrated, I think it's underrated.

Plus as a side note I think that the layout looks like a duck.

Honestly, wii rr aint even overrated... tbh is one of the most forgotten RR bc casual players just remember 3ds, snes o mk8 rr lol. Wii rr maybe didnt had any kind of new feature, but still being a really good climax por a special cup that almost everybody expect, unlike snes rr that sucks a lot.
maybe havent something pretty... original in theming but well tbf the rainbow road concept even on mk8 still being pretty bland, the most creative RR i guess that we all can agree that is 3ds rr.
And well any complain about the layout... is maybe bc starters haven't played so much, with playing that track like 3 or 4 times you get used to.. it happens with almost any track tbf.

About sky garden, i have split opinions, by one hand the theming is a amazing upgrade, now we all can say that is literally a sky garden i loved it so much, but for the other hand, the layout itself is mediocre, i mean if wasnt a retro track, then i wouldn't complain so much, but since its supposed to be a retro track, just like 3 parts of the track has some alike with the original ver and it sucks tbf, as you can see even the mario kart comunity did better remakes of sky garden, by example Toxturtle's one or any remake from mkwii or mk8 custom tracks.

And personally yep, i wanted to see Ds Rainbow Road on the BCP even if wii rr is my fav one, i mean ... DS RR HAS ANTIGRAVITY even without been on mk8 lol

ok, maybe i was just over exaggerating that wii rr is overrated lol. but yeah i do agree with you. Wii RR is forgotten and not really brought up a lot. but as for what you said about sky garden, sure, the layout was a tiny bit of a downgrade, but it's still one of the best GBA remakes imo, along with RP and BL. and with the final statement, i completely agree. DS RR has anti grav so it was an obvious pick for Nintendo but nope! they just decided to cash grab off of Wii nostalgia with Wii RR instead.

The most underrated BCP circuit imo is DS Mario Circuit and the most overrated is DK Mountain

Overated one: Maple Treeway, dont get me wrong, i luv the track but lets be honest, sometimes ppl overhype the track.

Underated one: Wuhu loop and Maka Wuhu, to be both the first sectional tracks, i loved so much both versions, i luv the alt patchs that both tracks has even if big part of them are kinda useless at time trials xd

Another Underated One: MK8 Mario Circuit, along with shy guy falls,wild woods and both F-Zero tracks, literally the only mk8 tracks that applys perfectly the antigravity.

Exact lol, even DS MC has a theming upgrade, Dk Mountain is a really good track ngl, but same case as maple treeway, pretty overblown how ppl put it as the best track or something like that

I think btw the best Wii Track is Mushroom Gorge even for the music but many ppl doesn't agrre that

dk summit is trash

As someone who likes shortcuts, that what makes a good track for me. Especially ones that are shroomless and higher in difficulty.

I AM WITH MY PEOPLE

Explain how

Also for another one, literally just found out today that people don't like London. Yeah it's a little bland, but the music slaps and there are some great obstacles. Idk why y'all say it feels slow. Hella underrated

I'm glad everyone who has posted thinks Waluigi Pinball is overrated.

This exists.