Geno

So, this topic may seem useless at first, but there are a few things I feel like I need to address about this guy. Because Geno...literally can not be made playable in Smash. I know that's a bold statement but bare with me here.

So, if you know ANYTHING about the plot of Mario RPG, you'd know that Geno...isn't truly a doll. They's either a being from outer space, or a spirit in the afterlife, but whichever one, they took the form of the doll because it looked the strongest of the dolls. Geno is actually the name of the doll, not the name of the spirit possesing the doll, meaning that when you say that you want Geno in Smash you're saying you want a random doll from a little kid's house in Smash. This raises a big question:
What the heck is the doll based on? Unless there are time travel shenanigans going on here, there's nothing that the doll could be based on, at least in the Mario universe.
As mentioned earlier, Geno isn't actually Geno's real name. His real name, in game, is "♥♩!?", and he just said to call him Geno because that's what the doll's name was.
Additionally, we don't really know if it's a he OR a she. If anything, it's probably BOTH, considering when they first meets Mario, they say "WE know about you!"
We also don't really know what ♥♩!? truly looks like, because as stated earlier, the Doll isn't their true appearance, it's just a form they're briefly borrowing so that they can help defeat Smithy Gang.
...so...
Stop asking for him in Smash, for the love of god, it won't be the same person, and if it is, it wouldn't make sense that he'd go in the random doll again just to fight a Shadow Thief, a Fast Hedgehog, and the person he helped a few years ago but a doctor.

smash  doesn't  really need logic to work, anything is possible in Nintendo games   i mean look at mario u got a giant   turtle kidnapping a princess in a world where a mustache man can grow bigger by eating magic  mushrooms i think logic has been thrown out the window if u ask me lol