Fixing MKDS Retro Selection
Page : 1
4859 - 
73987 pts ★ Titan
12573 pts ★ ChampionOn 2024-02-01 at 16:54:57
(important note this is not a collab project every collab project I tried to make recently failed lmao)
For those who don't know, Mario Kart DS was my first video game, and as much as I will always have it in my heart we can all agree that MKDS Retro Tracks sucks
When I say it sucks, it's as much for the selection as for the "remakes" themselves, and that's really one of the biggest flaws of MKDS imo
I just had a possibly interesting idea, asking which tracks everyone here would have liked to see in a "fixed" MKDS Retro Selection, so we can all make our MKDS Retro Selection, and a final track list at the end ^^
Well, I guess you can just list every track you want to see here (like GCN Peach Beach, N64 Toad's Turnpike etc...) or even make a complete track list
Just consider the fact that I'm going to stick to 4 tracks per game, but the order isn't important (like a SNES track can now be the 2nd, 3rd or 4th track of a cup)
Also I know i'm not clear at all so you can ask anything if you have a doubt on something if anyone ask "anything if you have a doubt on something" they'll get a warning ok ? 😈
For those who don't know, Mario Kart DS was my first video game, and as much as I will always have it in my heart we can all agree that MKDS Retro Tracks sucks
When I say it sucks, it's as much for the selection as for the "remakes" themselves, and that's really one of the biggest flaws of MKDS imo
I just had a possibly interesting idea, asking which tracks everyone here would have liked to see in a "fixed" MKDS Retro Selection, so we can all make our MKDS Retro Selection, and a final track list at the end ^^
Well, I guess you can just list every track you want to see here (like GCN Peach Beach, N64 Toad's Turnpike etc...) or even make a complete track list
Just consider the fact that I'm going to stick to 4 tracks per game, but the order isn't important (like a SNES track can now be the 2nd, 3rd or 4th track of a cup)
Also I know i'm not clear at all so you can ask anything if you have a doubt on something if anyone ask "anything if you have a doubt on something" they'll get a warning ok ? 😈
3
2
1
On 2024-02-01 at 17:22:36
Interesting idea, I like it! 
On 2024-02-01 at 17:30:14
i think that the retros need to be a little more like interesting cuz they feel bland in a way,
like mario circuit 1
https://www.mariouniverse.com/wp-content/img/maps/ds/mk/snes-mariocircuit-1.png
like mario circuit 1
https://www.mariouniverse.com/wp-content/img/maps/ds/mk/snes-mariocircuit-1.png
On 2024-02-01 at 19:15:04
tbh the MKDS retros are pretty fine to me, but i'd say a few things can be changed
tracks i would remove from the retros are SNES Choco Island 2 and SNES Koopa Beach 2. the ones i doubt are N64 Moo Moo Farm, GBA Peach Circuit, GBA Bowser Castle 2, and GCN Baby Park
now that any track (SNES-GCN) can get a chance be in the selection, i'll set up some candidates.
SNES Bowser Castle 2 and SNES Vanilla Lake 1 were probably hated tracks before 2004 (release of the Nintendo DS) so i felt like bringing them might be upsetting, meaning that SNES Koopa Beach 1 and SNES Ghost Valley 2 were the only ones left.
i just figured that having CPUs stop in N64 Kalimari Desert can be a task, so i decided it shouldn't be in it. there's already 2 car tracks in the game and thought that can be enough, so N64 Toad's Turnpike isnt coming back. although i never had a N64, N64 Mario Raceway felt better than N64 Moo Moo Farm.
Looking back at MKDS' GBA Bowser Castle 2 remake, i thought that i should keep it. GBA Riverside Park felt like something i should bring.
GCN Mario Circuit is in my selection because an unused model of the track was found in the files. (forgot to remove GCN Baby Park)
imo MKDS' retro track ordering would be kept.
tracks i would remove from the retros are SNES Choco Island 2 and SNES Koopa Beach 2. the ones i doubt are N64 Moo Moo Farm, GBA Peach Circuit, GBA Bowser Castle 2, and GCN Baby Park
now that any track (SNES-GCN) can get a chance be in the selection, i'll set up some candidates.
SNES Bowser Castle 2 and SNES Vanilla Lake 1 were probably hated tracks before 2004 (release of the Nintendo DS) so i felt like bringing them might be upsetting, meaning that SNES Koopa Beach 1 and SNES Ghost Valley 2 were the only ones left.
i just figured that having CPUs stop in N64 Kalimari Desert can be a task, so i decided it shouldn't be in it. there's already 2 car tracks in the game and thought that can be enough, so N64 Toad's Turnpike isnt coming back. although i never had a N64, N64 Mario Raceway felt better than N64 Moo Moo Farm.
Looking back at MKDS' GBA Bowser Castle 2 remake, i thought that i should keep it. GBA Riverside Park felt like something i should bring.
GCN Mario Circuit is in my selection because an unused model of the track was found in the files. (forgot to remove GCN Baby Park)
imo MKDS' retro track ordering would be kept.
3On 2024-02-01 at 20:25:24
If we keep that same pattern,
SNES Mario Circuit 2
N64 Kalimari Desert
GBA Riverside Park
GCN Peach Beach
SNES Donut Plains 2
N64 Toad's Turnpike
GBA Boo Lake
GCN Mushroom Bridge
SNES Ghost Valley 3
N64 Royal Raceway
GBA Sunset Wilds
GCN Mushroom City
SNES Vanilla Lake 2
N64 DK's Jungle Parkway
GBA Bowser Castle 4
GCN Rainbow Road
SNES Mario Circuit 2
N64 Kalimari Desert
GBA Riverside Park
GCN Peach Beach
SNES Donut Plains 2
N64 Toad's Turnpike
GBA Boo Lake
GCN Mushroom Bridge
SNES Ghost Valley 3
N64 Royal Raceway
GBA Sunset Wilds
GCN Mushroom City
SNES Vanilla Lake 2
N64 DK's Jungle Parkway
GBA Bowser Castle 4
GCN Rainbow Road
11
On 2024-02-01 at 20:47:59
Persos j'ai classé par thème :
SNES
Circuit Mario 2
Île Choco 2
Lac Vanille 1
Vallée fantôme 1
N64
Autodrome Mario
Route Glagla
Vallée Yoshi
Montagne Choco
GBA
Circuit Peach
Lakeside Park
Jardin Volant
Château de Bowser IV
GCN
Pont Champignon
Circuit Mario
Circuit Luigi
Stade Waluigi
SNES
Circuit Mario 2
Île Choco 2
Lac Vanille 1
Vallée fantôme 1
N64
Autodrome Mario
Route Glagla
Vallée Yoshi
Montagne Choco
GBA
Circuit Peach
Lakeside Park
Jardin Volant
Château de Bowser IV
GCN
Pont Champignon
Circuit Mario
Circuit Luigi
Stade Waluigi
1
On 2024-02-01 at 21:11:09
This it's how i going to try fix mario kart ds retro tracks:
Shell Cup:
SNES Mario Circuit 1
N64 Moo Moo Farm
GBA Riverside Park
GCN Dry Dry Desert
Banana Cup:
SNES Donut Plains 2
N64 Frappe Snowland
GBA Cheese Land
GCN Daisy Cruiser
Leaf Cup:
SNES Koopa Beach 1
N64 Royal Raceway
GBA Bowser Castle 3 (Yea I'm Crazy)
GCN Mushroom City
Lighthing Cup:
SNES Vanilla Lake 2 (I'm Crazy Once Again)
N64 Banshee Boardwalk
GBA Sky Garden
GCN Bowser's Castle
How did you guys think about this?
Shell Cup:
SNES Mario Circuit 1
N64 Moo Moo Farm
GBA Riverside Park
GCN Dry Dry Desert
Banana Cup:
SNES Donut Plains 2
N64 Frappe Snowland
GBA Cheese Land
GCN Daisy Cruiser
Leaf Cup:
SNES Koopa Beach 1
N64 Royal Raceway
GBA Bowser Castle 3 (Yea I'm Crazy)
GCN Mushroom City
Lighthing Cup:
SNES Vanilla Lake 2 (I'm Crazy Once Again)
N64 Banshee Boardwalk
GBA Sky Garden
GCN Bowser's Castle
How did you guys think about this?
2On 2024-02-09 at 18:38:03
welp since i haven't done a list for my version of a fixed MKDS retro selection i might as well do one
Shell Cup:
SNES Mario Circuit 1 (this is the only one that's staying, along with Mushroom Bridge and Choco Mountain)
N64 Koopa Troopa Beach
GBA Riverside Park
GCN Mushroom Bridge
Banana Cup:
SNES Bowser Castle 2
N64 Choco Mountain
GBA Sunset Wilds
GCN Daisy Cruiser
Leaf Cup:
SNES Vanilla Lake 1
N64 DK's Jungle Parkway
GBA Ribbon Road
GCN Mushroom City
Lightning Cup:
SNES Ghost Valley 3
N64 Wario Stadium
GBA Lakeside Park (yes i'm including both parks because i'm out of ideas)
GCN Rainbow Road (i had no ideas so i picked this)
Shell Cup:
SNES Mario Circuit 1 (this is the only one that's staying, along with Mushroom Bridge and Choco Mountain)
N64 Koopa Troopa Beach
GBA Riverside Park
GCN Mushroom Bridge
Banana Cup:
SNES Bowser Castle 2
N64 Choco Mountain
GBA Sunset Wilds
GCN Daisy Cruiser
Leaf Cup:
SNES Vanilla Lake 1
N64 DK's Jungle Parkway
GBA Ribbon Road
GCN Mushroom City
Lightning Cup:
SNES Ghost Valley 3
N64 Wario Stadium
GBA Lakeside Park (yes i'm including both parks because i'm out of ideas)
GCN Rainbow Road (i had no ideas so i picked this)
1Page : 1