I'll rate your Mario Kart PC tracks.

I know this is similar to Cooking_Papa's article, but I will also rate complete mode tracks (not just quick mode).

Here's how I'll be rating them:

Each track will get an overall score of 30 points. If it gets 24 or higher it will put it on my list of recommended custom tracks. The list will be published in no more than a month from now.

Track layout 1-10: The turns, the jumps, etc.

Track visuals 1-10: The theme, the colors, the extra details, etc.

Track fun and creativity 1-10: Difficulty, good use of drifting and tricking, good placing and number of item boxes, etc.

The scores from each of those will be added up and then get a final number. Like I said, if it gets a total score of 24 or higher, it will be listed on my list of most recommended tracks.

[Remember I accept both quick mode AND complete mode tracks]

Please will someone post their track for me to rank?

here are some SNES tracks


Ghost Valley 1
https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=229673

Mario Circuit 3
https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=229680

Donut Plains 1
https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=229672

Ghost Valley 1

Layout: 6: Since it's a SNES track the layout isn't as great but it's still got nice turns and fun places to trick off of.

Visuals: 10: I love the guys in the audience cheering you on. The ghosts are cool too. Also, I really anjoy the item panels. The koopas and shy guys and toads make it feel like a real Mario Kart track.

Fun: 8: The shortcuts are a good addition and they are fun to pull off. The way you get 2 items right off of the start makes it chaotic in a good way.

Your total score is 24! That means it will be listed on my list of recommended mkpc tracks.

Mario Circuit 3

Layout: 6: No jumps but way better drifting turns than the last one.

Visuals: 10: Again, I love the panels and guys in the audience but...this track did something I couldn't imagine. You made it go underground and turn into an anti gravity section. That was so creative and fun.

Fun: 10: Like I said, the underground anti gravity part made this track so surprisingly great.

Total Score is 26! This track is very good and will be put on my list.

Donut Plains 1

Layout: 5: This one had some good turns but was longer than it should've been.

Visuals: 8: The thing that brings this so high is again the little guys in the audience and the item panels. Besides that it's just that SNES track remade.

Fun: 6: Still enjoyable to race on, but can be kinda slow and boring in some parts.

Total score is 19. Didn't quite make it to the list.

Overall very good tracks.

wdym there arent jumps on mc3???

bro I'm so dumb I was looking out for those yellow bars since they were SNES tracks. But now that I'm playing it again yea there are jumps. Sorry for the inconvienience.

Feel free to post a link to your track here so I can rate it

Man I hope my track is good, I'm not the greatest artist, but maybe you could like it

Frozen Caves

I am honestly not offended if you hate it

Layout: 6: Nice turns and jumps and speed panels. But the road is very narrow and very easy to fall off of.

Visuals: 4: It is a very pretty basic track, but I like the pirhana plants and the I like the snowman, but they can be a tricky obstacle.

Fun: 5: I liked driving around on the track and the turns are fun to pull off, but this track is pretty long which means it can get boring or even frustrating at some points.

This track got a score of 15/30. Not bad but it didn't make it to the list of my most recommended tracks (24 or higher).

It's a pretty decent track and I for sure don't hate it but it might need a little more work on it. Keep working on your tracks, they'll keep getting better and better!

N64 Koopa Troopa Beach - https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=194471

Layout: 8: Very faithful to the original. Yet, similar to the original, the layout is pretty basic with not as many jumps or tight turns. I enjoy going through the shortcut though and boosting on the dash panels. It is still a very nice layout.

Visuals: 7: Again, pretty basic. The palm trees make this track feel tropical and the dash panels are cool colors. Also the visuals are close to the original, which isn't bad. I'm impressed with how accurate this is.

Fun: 9: Enjoyable to race on. I also like that how long it takes to beat it is very accurate to how long it takes to normally beat it on the N64. Very shocked on how accurate this track was.

This track got a 24/30, meaning it will be on my recommended tracks list! Very good track. Keep working on more tracks and you'll get better and better!

Nice.

Just Dont Review My Rainbow Road Deluxe Track (its still on WIP, although desing wise its pretty much finished :d)

Layout: 9: I love the jumps and speed panels, the turns are really good too. Also the inclusion of rail riding surprised me.

Visuals: 8: Great Visuals. Very colorful. Use of pipes and trees make the course feel fun.

Fun: 10: I really enjoyed racing on this track.
Like, this was a really good track! It's not too long like some other tracks I've raced on. It has a good vibe and feels nice to race on. The speed panels and jumps are really fun, plus the rail riding! This track is awesome and you should be proud of it.

You scored a 27/30! That's the highest score yet on this post! This one will be featured on my list of most recommended custom tracks.

barn race

Layout: 7: I was surprised by how many good turns there were here. I'm being completely honest they were cool to pull off! The pipes and moles make this track really tricky to drive on though.

Visuals: 4: Nothing much but the pipes and the moles. Then again, this is a quick mode track and it looks nicely decorated for a quick one.

Fun: 4: The first lap was fun because I somehow got passed all of the monty moles and pipes. I loved drifting in the first lap BUT then the second lap came. I ran into most of the moles and pipes, and because of that I couldn't drift well. There are way too many pipes.

Total Score is 15/30. Not terrible, but not that great either. Keep working on your tracks and keep getting better!

cap race

Layout: 5: Ok first off why did you choose Luigi's Mansion?? That one is tricky for quick mode because of how narrow the paths are. Hard to drift turns cane be a pain. But I like the inclusion of a shortcut towards the beginning and that bumpy section with the jumps.

Visuals: 2: Uh so yeah. I like the way you put the mansion crossroad in it even though it didn't need a crossroad. But the mansion looks cool, right? Well, there's only one incident of this in the course and the rest isn't well decorated.

Fun: 3: This track was pretty boring. Also it feels too crowded with 8 people racing. My suggestion is change the track map at least to something like figure 8 Circuit or something more wide at least.

Total Score: 10/30. This track needs improving, but don't worry. Each time you make a track you get better and better at it.

Feel free to check out my tracks too

Here's mine
https://mkpc.malahieude.net/circuit.php?id=237472

And my other one
https://mkpc.malahieude.net/circuit.php?id=237357

Here's both of your track's scores:

Mario Circuit 2 but it's Ghost Valley

Layout: 6: It is a SNES track, so the layout is pretty basic. I like how you fused to tracks together though. THe item boxes all being against the wall is an interesting decision. Idk if you were trying to mimic the panels or what but yeah. Pretty solid.

Visuals: 4: I mean, it's just Ghost Valley. Pretty much just a boardwalk. Not bad, but needs some extra stuff.

Fun: 7: Idk why, but I really like the turns of Mario Circuit 2. Definitely the best SNES Mario Circuit. It's fun to play a familiar track in a spooky setting.

Total score is 17/30. Needs improvement, but otherwise it's pretty decent.

Race 4 buses

Layout: 7: Lots of fun turns, but there were too many speed jumps.

Visuals: 9: The buses were a really creative idea! If it didn't have them, this score would be a lot lower.

Fun: 8: Really fun to race against the buses. This track was so chaotic it made this track really fun!

Total Score is 24! This track will be on my most recommended track list. Also, it's the first quick mode track to be on there !