0
No notifications
0
notification
Home
Play game
Forum
List of comments from -Jade- (464)
5/5 you can race on it as a Pikmin
Ok seriously this is really good, I love the idea and vibe
In
Lostwater Forest
yesterday at 13:12:29
This is pretty good as well tbh, 4/5
In
DS Waluigi Pinball (Quick Mode)
yesterday at 13:08:59
This is actual peak for a newer track creator well done 5/5
In
Super Mario Galxy
yesterday at 12:38:24
Yeah that was intentional lol
In
Piranha Plant Pipeline
on 2026-07-28 at 23:10:09
Hello I made the Fuzzies ok this is peak 5/5 love you Chloe babe ok bye bye
In
Piranha Plant Pipeline
on 2026-07-28 at 21:59:20
5/5 tbh, the graphics are a bit eh but that's literally it
In
DK Summit
on 2026-07-21 at 13:58:26
No
In
Ninji cup
on 2026-07-19 at 15:40:43
They seem to have an unhealthy obsession with Bowser Jr. characters
In
Mario kart ds
on 2026-07-19 at 13:52:04
Hold up am I fucking seeing this correctly
Is FryGuy cooking
5/5
In
Mario Circuit 2
on 2026-07-18 at 18:09:02
HOLY PEAK
Babe how tf do your tracks get better every time 5/5
In
Mario Circuit 2
on 2026-07-17 at 23:01:02
5/5 on 8 reviews yet I seem to be the only reviewer leaving a comment at the time of writing /j
Jokes aside this is a really fucking good remake, I love the use of different "areas" (for example the cave/tunnel) that gives it a lot more personality than the original. The strawberry decor is also such a cute touch, and I love how this actually feels like it's taking place on an island despite a lack of decor on the main track (which is completely fine btw)
Easy 5/5
In
Choco Island 2
on 2026-06-05 at 19:23:18
This is AWESOME! Everyone who took part in this did a great job
In
Baby Park
on 2026-06-01 at 14:11:48
Yoooo Sariel mentioned
I LOVE this but some turns are really tight imo 4/5
In
Fallen Temple
on 2026-05-27 at 00:43:06
How have I not properly rated this yet xD
Gameplay - 9/10
The layout is virtually perfect, it just relies a little too heavily on grass cuts for my liking (only deducted one point cus I don't see any reason to rate it down too harshly lol)
Graphics - 5/5
The textures are all great and I can clearly tell what kind of environment I'm in when playing
Replayability - 5/5
The fact I didn't review this before is honestly criminal, I love replaying this to find new routes
Theming - 4/5
It's nothing too out there but the theming, albeit quite simple, was executed perfectly
Decor - 3/3
Amazing decor, I like how it doesn't rely on vanilla decor too
Music - 1/1
Really fits the mountain theme
Personal bias - 1/1
Honestly one of the best tracks I've played thus far
Total - 28/30 (middle 5 stars)
You cooked on this one Nodac, honestly the only things I'd recommend fixing are entirely subjective
In
Mushroom Mountain
on 2026-04-19 at 14:28:44
Yeah no, I can't lie this is a prime example of why prioritising quantity over quality barely ever (if ever, that is) leads to good results. I definitely see the vision in wanting to put every retro track in an easy-to-access multicup for others to play but in doing so I fear the effort and quality I'd expect isn't quite there in many of the tracks. It's a 2/5 from me. Just try to prioritise quality a little more and this would be pretty damn good.
In
Retro Rewind In MKPC! v3.7
on 2026-04-15 at 21:15:14
Yeah honestly I'm lowering my rating to a 3/5 it's such a nothing burger even if it's nice
In
Cycad Oaklands
on 2026-04-04 at 07:25:57
Just removed my vote because this is genuinely pissing me off, feeling like I need to explain myself constantly over a 3/5 rating just because I used to have beef with the creator (which was completely unrelated to track making in the first place) is stupid
In
Fungal Wastes
on 2026-04-02 at 11:17:43
I understand how it probably came off when the others sort of followed up with 1-3 star ratings though and as I've said before I literally didn't anticipate that
In
Fungal Wastes
on 2026-04-01 at 11:07:32
Honestly if I wanted to spite Nudgy I would've rated this a 1/5 without an explanation nor even playing the track
In
Fungal Wastes
on 2026-04-01 at 11:06:13
Yeah to be fair I'm terrible at explaining things, and I somehow get stressed when people don't understand what I'm saying LOL
In
Fungal Wastes
on 2026-04-01 at 11:01:24
Page: 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
Back to the profile
Back to the forum
List of comments from -Jade- (464)
Ok seriously this is really good, I love the idea and vibe
Is FryGuy cooking
5/5
Babe how tf do your tracks get better every time 5/5
Jokes aside this is a really fucking good remake, I love the use of different "areas" (for example the cave/tunnel) that gives it a lot more personality than the original. The strawberry decor is also such a cute touch, and I love how this actually feels like it's taking place on an island despite a lack of decor on the main track (which is completely fine btw)
Easy 5/5
I LOVE this but some turns are really tight imo 4/5
Gameplay - 9/10
The layout is virtually perfect, it just relies a little too heavily on grass cuts for my liking (only deducted one point cus I don't see any reason to rate it down too harshly lol)
Graphics - 5/5
The textures are all great and I can clearly tell what kind of environment I'm in when playing
Replayability - 5/5
The fact I didn't review this before is honestly criminal, I love replaying this to find new routes
Theming - 4/5
It's nothing too out there but the theming, albeit quite simple, was executed perfectly
Decor - 3/3
Amazing decor, I like how it doesn't rely on vanilla decor too
Music - 1/1
Really fits the mountain theme
Personal bias - 1/1
Honestly one of the best tracks I've played thus far
Total - 28/30 (middle 5 stars)
You cooked on this one Nodac, honestly the only things I'd recommend fixing are entirely subjective
Page: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24
Back to the forum