List of comments from -Jade- (464)

Plain answer: NO, it's not just the name, even if that was misleading

Damn it's not like I've posted several messages explaining why I think this is a 3/5, the name is literally just one of several reasons, and honestly a pretty small one at that

I just thought maybe I needed to explain one of my gripes in more detail because me and Nudgy haven't exactly been on the best terms in the past and it might have seemed like I just gave a less than perfect rating to spite him or something petty like that

Anyway I think some of the reason I'm not too keen on this track is because it feels like you sort of HAVE to play HK to understand it? I guess the same could apply for 3/4 of the other top TBC tracks too but this one just felt like the biggest example of that. The name "Fungal Wastes" is sort of misleading to me (someone who hasn't played HK), I expected an arid, derelict landscape but it's an overgrown swamp with glowing turquoise acid, which kinda threw me off (also the fact that I don't like such harsh shades of turquoise personally doesn't help). In terms of layout the track isn't egregious I guess, I just feel like I've grown averse to 90 degree turns after it ruined so many of my old tracks. This'll remain at 3/5 in my opinion, but I can definitely see the appeal to you guys (for the mushroom theming this was really good though, even though the track itself isn't my cup of tea lol)

Honestly it's really petty to shit on a track just cus you have beef with the creator

Yeah we're ico spheres in Blender

This is getting a 1/5, the layout is lazy as fuck and the decor is just atrocious, I'm not even gonna bother doing a full breakdown like I usually do

Average low effort QM track lol

Also I'd refrain from making tracks about something so controversial please

Dante's Inferno isn't in the Bible how about you read a fucking book

Amazing babe :3

UNK is Ultra Nudge Kart I think? Pls correct if I'm wrong

Ah ok ok thank you for that, I didn't realise

Theming is going up to a 4/5 but it's still rated 3/5 overall

I didn't take that into account because I'm not rating this as a TBC track, I'm rating it as I would a regular track

The mushroom theming is good but I feel it takes away from the wasteland theming

Anyway I apologise for the other bad ratings this track got, I genuinely didn't anticipate that

God how dare I rate a track 3/5 that I don't like smh

To give a full breakdown of why I rated it 3/5:

Gameplay - 5/10
It's mostly fine but the indoor section in the bottom-left corner of the track is genuinely awful

Graphics - 2/5
The textures are alright but the colouration is garish

Replayability - 4/5
It's quite fun to replay honestly, even though I think it's flawed

Theming - 2/5
Dunno what else to rate this since I'm not a HK player, but this looks more like a forest than a wasteland, maybe it's supposed to be a swamp or smth so it's not abhorrent ig
[EDIT: Thanks for clarifying Poofie! The rating above is now obsolete, this has gone from 2/5 to 4/5]

Decor - 2/3
It looks nice but nothing I'd gush over

Music - 1/1
It's from HK so I can't rate it down

Personal bias - 0/1
Honestly one of my least favourite of your tracks

Total - 16/30 (mid-range 3/5)
[Amended: 18/30 (mid/high 3/5)]

I'll add improvement notes later cus I have stuff to do

Sorry but this is getting a 3/5 from me, the colours are garish and the gameplay in the indoor section is probably some of the worst I've seen from a good track creator 💀 Aside from that it's alright I guess

Congrats to Ahmad, Hazel and Crafto for being the first three people to complete the challenge!

Oh I still made this in Pixilart I just have a completely new style (sorry for the late response :p)

This is awesome darling holy shit 5/5

Just changed a jump height issue I found with a few of the gummy bears