0
No notifications
0
notification
Home
Play game
Forum
Comments list of BFDI_Ahmad16 (280)
But only one of them will get in. Which remake will be the one that will get it? Find out on Total Drama Island!!!
In
hoppingicon's Mario Kart Bundle Deluxe
on 2022-02-17 at 23:40:11
But Lely is right in some ways hoppingicon. The only tracks I disagree with Lely is Mushroom Gorge (Because it's fine as it is) and Mario Circuit (Because cannons are better than warpers and the white outlines is the image itself)
In
Mario Kart Wii
on 2022-02-17 at 13:16:06
Thank you very much for your comment Fways. :)
In
MK1(O) Luigi's City (Luigi's Highway)
on 2022-02-16 at 23:33:35
Thank you so much for your feedback zed. I read the entire review about this remake. Yeah some shortcuts aren't really needed but they still serve a purpose to taking them and I think it's a good addition. Yes the pipes block it along with a hidden wall collisions so you don't get stuck with the pipe collisions. I do plan to add cones though. The path being confusing in the original version wasn't much of a problem for me. It was just how annoying it was to play with the boost panel placements and trick ramps and even buses so that's why I remade this track. Again, thank you for your feedback zed. ^^
In
MK1(O) Luigi's City (Luigi's Highway)
on 2022-02-16 at 23:30:49
Okay guys, first of all I'm sorry for not publishing a track for 5 and a half months. I've been lazy doing tracks plus if I start a remake, I normally don't have motivation to continue most of the times and this remake was almost one of them until I finally picked it up and tried my best to bring out a great remake. I hope you guys enjoy this remake. ^^
Credits: Angel121 for the red mushroom towers.
MyNintendoGhost for the GCN Mushroom City towers.
hoppingicon for the mushroom houses and domes.
Ahmad14 (Me) for Luigi's/1-UP tower and traffic lights.
NotoBook6 for the improved version of my tower.
Toad64 for the Jellyfish and Dolphin decors and lastly,
Patrik_Laine for the lampposts.
In
MK1(O) Luigi's City (Luigi's Highway)
on 2022-02-16 at 23:01:03
https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=25341 Here is the original version.
In
CTGP-7 Gba Sky Garden
on 2022-02-12 at 00:25:59
Gameplay
Layout changes if needed (Adding shortcuts, new paths, changing the main road layout etc) = 3/3
Design (No trick ramp right before the corner, make the route clear and easy to follow, etc) = 2/3
Collisions (Walls, checkpoints, offroad etc) = 2/3
Obstacles (Goombas, Buses, Snow balls etc) = 2/3
Total for gameplay: 9/12
Decoration
Visual upgrade (Better visuals than the original version) = 2/2
Theming (Theming can be slightly different as long as it's not too drastic) = 2/2
Decoration upgrade (MKPC decors and the art itself decor as long as it fits the track) = 2/2
Music (Appropriate for the track) = 1/1
Background (MKPC background and the art itself background) = 1/1
Total for decoration: 8/8
Total for all: 17/20
This is a very good remake. It took one of my favorite MK1(O) tracks and made it better in visuals and gameplay. The visuals are phenomenal, it's a huge upgrade from the original version and I also really love the decor. They look very fantastic. Even the gameplay is improved by a bit. I love the layout changes to this track and the moving water is very good too. I also like how the shortcut in the original version is included in this version. As much as I love the visuals and gameplay, there is some flaws I'll mention here.
1. The collision for the walls seems strange as when you take that first path into the tube, some of the lines are actually holes so that's weird and the ending cannon can shoot you down to the holes when you drift into the cannon so I would suggest it to be extended by a little bit.
2. The obstacles can be a little annoying with the cheep cheeps at the beginning and that goomba at the end so I would probably move them somewhere else where it's less annoying especially for the goomba.
3. The design is good but some areas can be improved like the first path boost jump, I don't recommend putting it right before the corner and for the split paths, I like that it's improved however some things can be fixed. The way to do the shortcut has been nerfed so it's easier but on the other hand, it saves much more time than the original version and any other routes save way less time than the shortcut which I like on the original version because it was very skill based and if you fail, you have to go on the other route which loses time and while the same is applied here, it doesn't feel as balanced. This is where I feel that it's not really your fault and it's more on the original track to be honest. My suggestion for that is try to balance the route and for the shortcut, if it's going to be easier, it should save less time in my opinion. Overall, despite these flaws, this is still a really really good remake and I love every single bit about it.
I'm giving a 5/5 for this remake, Mudky. Continue to make awesome remakes like this one. :)
In
MK1(O) - Dragon Bay / Baie du Dragon
on 2022-02-08 at 20:58:47
Also it got 2 stared troll. I literally do not see why these tracks are deserving of 2 stars just because they are "too wide".
In
Mario Kart 5 (O)
on 2022-02-03 at 19:51:07
Some tracks are wide, yes but they have a lot going on when you compare it to MK1(O) which has very wide tracks for no reason so I think the size for these tracks here are perfect and doesn't need changing at all.
In
Mario Kart 5 (O)
on 2022-02-02 at 18:13:20
One of the track creators deleted his MK8 track remakes and it was in the Mushroom and Flower Cup (The actual one, not the one that's shown) so that explains the 2 cups that is not there.
In
Mario Kart 8
on 2022-01-26 at 18:25:04
For the last lap, it is BTS I'm Fine Piano Cover. I would suggest to put back the Mario Kart 8 Rainbow Road final lap soundtrack.
In
Mario Kart 1 (L) - Galarc-en-ciel
on 2022-01-23 at 19:35:26
Thank you for your feedback. I like that you took time to write long feedbacks. I read all of it and I agree with everything you said. Yeah this remake is technically better than the original but it's practically the same just with minor changes and this was my first retro track and I didn't understand what "remake" meant so I made a port instead. Don't worry, a new version of this track is coming with much better layout, visuals and gameplay. ^^
In
MK1(O) Vallee Fantome
on 2022-01-23 at 12:23:08
Which is probably gonna take a lot longer than expected. Look I hate to keep delaying the remake but I really just seem to get motivated to actually finish the track. Hopefully in the upcoming weeks, I will finish my GCN Bowser's Castle remake.
In
Wario's Gold Mine
on 2022-01-19 at 07:25:41
1. The shortcut at the end doesn't slow you down, it saves a lot of time with a single mushroom.
2. The cheep cheep at the start wasn't supposed to hit the middle whatsoever. It was meant to just cross from the left area of the road to the right and vice versa. Also that's more on the behavior of the decor so me and hoppingicon can't do much about it.
In
SNES Ghost Valley 3
on 2022-01-13 at 20:55:32
Gameplay
Layout changes if needed (Adding shortcuts, new paths, changing the main road layout etc) = 3/3
Design (No trick ramp right before the corner, make the route clear and easy to follow, etc) = 2.5/3
Collisions (Walls, checkpoints, offroad etc) = 2.5/3
Obstacles (Goombas, Buses, Snow balls etc) = 2.5/3
Total for gameplay: 10.5/12
Decoration
Visual upgrade (Better visuals than the original version) = 2/2
Theming (Theming can be slightly different as long as it's not too drastic) = 2/2
Decoration upgrade (MKPC decors and the art itself decor as long as it fits the track) = 2/2
Music (Appropriate for the track) = 1/1
Background (MKPC background and the art itself background) = 1/1
Total for decoration : 8/8
Total for all: 18.5/20
I really like this remake a lot. It took possible one of the worst MKPC tracks ever and improved it by really really a lot. The layout is great, the visuals is amazing, decor is very good and fitting for the track and the gameplay is also really good. I love this remake but there's a few issues.
1. The wall collisions is good but in few parts, it could be better but it's still great for the most part.
2. The design is good however I would not recommend adding a corner right after the cannon for your future tracks.
3. That's probably just me but you can get immediately hit by the boulders if you go too far to the left or right of the road. I would add like 1 or 2 goombas in that empty left section. Other than that, this remake is fantastic and I love all the improvements you've made in this version. Easily one of my favorite tracks from MK1(L) and all your other complete mode tracks Lely. 5/5 for sure, awesome job Lely and continue to do really good remakes like this one. :)
In
Mario Kart 1 (L) - Baie Noki
on 2022-01-13 at 19:11:26
Thanks and this is a remake of the original track. Here it is: https://mkpc.malahieude.net/map.php?i=30469
In
MK3(O) Bibliothèque Hantée
on 2022-01-12 at 17:11:12
I don't think me and Lely was being mean at all? We just gave our constructive criticism, nothing wrong with that. We just want you to improve in your track making skills.
In
Luigi is mad meme
on 2022-01-03 at 05:20:51
I changed the link so the track should work now.
In
GCN Mushroom Bridge
on 2022-01-01 at 16:24:28
He cannot do that at all. You can't just the collision of the object or obstacle itself. You can talk to Wargor about the buses going through with a star or mega. :)
In
Mushroom Cup
on 2022-01-01 at 02:23:46
Jeremiah Harris, can I use your decors like any of them? I'll give you credit. ^^
In
Jeremiah Kart PC
on 2021-12-27 at 20:21:18
Page :
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
Back to the profile
Back to the forum
Comments list of BFDI_Ahmad16 (280)
Credits: Angel121 for the red mushroom towers.
MyNintendoGhost for the GCN Mushroom City towers.
hoppingicon for the mushroom houses and domes.
Ahmad14 (Me) for Luigi's/1-UP tower and traffic lights.
NotoBook6 for the improved version of my tower.
Toad64 for the Jellyfish and Dolphin decors and lastly,
Patrik_Laine for the lampposts.
Layout changes if needed (Adding shortcuts, new paths, changing the main road layout etc) = 3/3
Design (No trick ramp right before the corner, make the route clear and easy to follow, etc) = 2/3
Collisions (Walls, checkpoints, offroad etc) = 2/3
Obstacles (Goombas, Buses, Snow balls etc) = 2/3
Total for gameplay: 9/12
Decoration
Visual upgrade (Better visuals than the original version) = 2/2
Theming (Theming can be slightly different as long as it's not too drastic) = 2/2
Decoration upgrade (MKPC decors and the art itself decor as long as it fits the track) = 2/2
Music (Appropriate for the track) = 1/1
Background (MKPC background and the art itself background) = 1/1
Total for decoration: 8/8
Total for all: 17/20
This is a very good remake. It took one of my favorite MK1(O) tracks and made it better in visuals and gameplay. The visuals are phenomenal, it's a huge upgrade from the original version and I also really love the decor. They look very fantastic. Even the gameplay is improved by a bit. I love the layout changes to this track and the moving water is very good too. I also like how the shortcut in the original version is included in this version. As much as I love the visuals and gameplay, there is some flaws I'll mention here.
1. The collision for the walls seems strange as when you take that first path into the tube, some of the lines are actually holes so that's weird and the ending cannon can shoot you down to the holes when you drift into the cannon so I would suggest it to be extended by a little bit.
2. The obstacles can be a little annoying with the cheep cheeps at the beginning and that goomba at the end so I would probably move them somewhere else where it's less annoying especially for the goomba.
3. The design is good but some areas can be improved like the first path boost jump, I don't recommend putting it right before the corner and for the split paths, I like that it's improved however some things can be fixed. The way to do the shortcut has been nerfed so it's easier but on the other hand, it saves much more time than the original version and any other routes save way less time than the shortcut which I like on the original version because it was very skill based and if you fail, you have to go on the other route which loses time and while the same is applied here, it doesn't feel as balanced. This is where I feel that it's not really your fault and it's more on the original track to be honest. My suggestion for that is try to balance the route and for the shortcut, if it's going to be easier, it should save less time in my opinion. Overall, despite these flaws, this is still a really really good remake and I love every single bit about it.
I'm giving a 5/5 for this remake, Mudky. Continue to make awesome remakes like this one. :)
2. The cheep cheep at the start wasn't supposed to hit the middle whatsoever. It was meant to just cross from the left area of the road to the right and vice versa. Also that's more on the behavior of the decor so me and hoppingicon can't do much about it.
Layout changes if needed (Adding shortcuts, new paths, changing the main road layout etc) = 3/3
Design (No trick ramp right before the corner, make the route clear and easy to follow, etc) = 2.5/3
Collisions (Walls, checkpoints, offroad etc) = 2.5/3
Obstacles (Goombas, Buses, Snow balls etc) = 2.5/3
Total for gameplay: 10.5/12
Decoration
Visual upgrade (Better visuals than the original version) = 2/2
Theming (Theming can be slightly different as long as it's not too drastic) = 2/2
Decoration upgrade (MKPC decors and the art itself decor as long as it fits the track) = 2/2
Music (Appropriate for the track) = 1/1
Background (MKPC background and the art itself background) = 1/1
Total for decoration : 8/8
Total for all: 18.5/20
I really like this remake a lot. It took possible one of the worst MKPC tracks ever and improved it by really really a lot. The layout is great, the visuals is amazing, decor is very good and fitting for the track and the gameplay is also really good. I love this remake but there's a few issues.
1. The wall collisions is good but in few parts, it could be better but it's still great for the most part.
2. The design is good however I would not recommend adding a corner right after the cannon for your future tracks.
3. That's probably just me but you can get immediately hit by the boulders if you go too far to the left or right of the road. I would add like 1 or 2 goombas in that empty left section. Other than that, this remake is fantastic and I love all the improvements you've made in this version. Easily one of my favorite tracks from MK1(L) and all your other complete mode tracks Lely. 5/5 for sure, awesome job Lely and continue to do really good remakes like this one. :)
Page : 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
Back to the forum