Comments list of TheNudgyHampter (1529)

Anyway, realised I didnt rate it, so here it is (Only gonna do a brief overview of the 2 sections instead of an explination for each individual thing, but if you have any questions, ask)

Gameplay: 8.5/12
Layout - 1/2
Design - 2/3
Variety - 1/2
Collisions - 2/2
Decors - 1/1
Other - 1.5/2
Overview: Feels too straight

Art: 6/8
Visuals: 2/2
Theming: 2/2
Decorations: 1/2
Music: 0/1
Background: 1/1
Overview: Rainbow looks good, but planets look off

Overall: 14.5/20
- 3.625/5
- 4/5

LETS GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

When I reremake this I’ll try adding more color, like maybe making the sans more red

Just added 2 goombas after the bridge

Dw at least you can say it has better graphics than this https://mkpc.malahieude.net/circuit.php?id=126015

I love the addition of the white stuff on the roads, the person who added them is a genius

Gameplay: 12/12
Layout: 2 - No problems with the layout
Design: 3 - All the separate parts work well together
Variety: 2 - Good amount of sections while still fitting the theme
Collisions: 2 - While there are no holes, that work fine here since holes don't fit the theme
Decors: 1 - Fit while making the gameplay fun
Other: 2 - The extra stuff are incorporated to be fun but not out of place

Art: 8/8
Looks: 2 - While there is quite a lot of grey, the grass section and the white stuff on the road help improve the colors, alongisde the other colored parts
Theming: 2 - It's a city with lots of boost pads
Decorarion: 2 - Lots of decoration, such as the houses, markets (or at least I think they are) and the different cars all help decorate it
Music: 1 - Music fits and sounds good
Background: 1 - Background fits and looks good

Overall: 20/20 -> 5/5
Didn't expect a perfect score to come so fast

Tbf if a track is inaccurate to the title then that essentially means you are clickbating people which is bad

Gameplay: 9.5/12
Layout: 1.5 - Accurate but long, though this length is balanced out by the shortcuts.
Design: 2 - Some parts aren't the most site-readable, such as the mushrooms.
Variety: 2 - Good variety of sections
Collisions: 2 - Good amount of holes, walls and off-road
Decors: 1 - Good decors which are fun to dodge
Other: 1 - Jumps aren't the best, with some which I feel launhh you in unfavourable ways, such as an awkward jump that lands at a decor somethimes, and a jump which uts you so high you have to wait a few seconds to get speed again

Art: 7/8
Looks: 2 - Looks good
Theming: 2 - Fits the og theming while also fitting the name
Decorations: 1.5 - The decorations are too much in some areas
Music: 0.5 - Fits some parts of the track but not others
Background: 1 - Fits the track
Overall: 16.5/20 -> 4.125/5, rounded up to 5/5

Just realised I forgot decors in gameplay which bumps it up to 12.5/20 -> 3.125/5, and due to me always rounding up, thats 4/5

Yeah it totally lost 2 stars from just the details alone

Me: Explains my reasons for the rating, even using a rating system to get an accurate rating
Max: how the fuck this is a 3/5 lmaooo

Gameplay: 7/12
Layout: 1 - While the layout is accurate, it does feel like it's too long
Design: 2 - While the track does have interesting design, many sections just feel out of place
Variety: 2 - Good variety of sections
Collisions: 1 - A couple walls missing at the crystal section, and it could to some off-road
Decors: 1 - Decors are good
Other: 1 - Problems with the teleporters, with them not extending over the whole pipe, and also the one at the shortcut at the start being too inconsistent

Art: 4.5/8
Looks: 2 - The track art is good
Theming: 1 - The 'Underground' part is shown off, but the only part which shows that it's a 'Monorail' are the parts outside the track, making it more of extra decorations
Decoration: 1 - The decorations do look good, but it feels like too much is going on
Music: 0.5 - Kinda bland, but I guess it fits
Background: 0 - Doesn't look very underground if you ask me

Overall: 11.5/20 -> 2.875/5
Due to my method, it always gets rounded up (in this case it would anyway) so it's 3/5

Skill issue detected

Now it's at a rating better than 5/5

Now imagine if this didn't have stolen circuits

Gave the French version and actual name now

Idk if there will be a race basd on it, but I might do a track with a mini cave section which looks like this

Nice

Annoying turn
Mid looks
Nothing interesting gameplay wise
Too many cannons
Confusing in terms of what classes is walls or off-road